With all the hyperbole around about “the cloud” these days, it’s a question that often gets asked. Recently I was asked by a prospective client to quote on a replacement server with two options.
1) A Microsoft Windows Domain Controller (DC), file and print server for 12 users with outsourced (cloud) exchange services. A hybrid of conventional and cloud.
2) A Microsoft Small Business Server (DC, File, Print, Email) for the same number of users.
I’ve always been a little negative about hosting out all your needs to the cloud as every pricing exercise I’ve done in the past has worked out way more expensive. Besides that the performance leaves a lot to be desired and the cost alone of a 5% productivity hit to the average annual payroll would cost way more than the average server.
Email – Now that’s another story, and if we think about it, a simple file and print server v’s a fully blown Small business server represents a big difference in capital outlay. Speed is not quite so important here as it only takes a few nanoseconds for an email to get from NZ to say London. Perhaps the cloud could be a good idea.
So here is the costing exercise we did for the customer.
Assumptions made:
- If the SBS server scenario were used then our MX filtering service (CTScleanmail) would be used to filter out spam and viruses.(Provides the same level of protection as Cloud email)
- That the CT cloud email service would be used at $8.60 mailbox month.
- That the server(s) would be leased over a three year period.
Option1: (Hybrid Model)
File and Print Server for 12 Users 1,876 capex monthly lease $75.83
Cloud based exchange services 12 users monthly fee $98.40
Total $174.23
Option2: (Conventional Model)
Small business server for 12 users $4,255 capex monthly lease $160.39
MX Filtering services (CTScleanmail) monthly fee $41.52
Total $201.91
Result
It can be clearly seen that in this hybrid scenario that the combination of Just a simple server for your file and print and outsourced exchange makes good sense. There’s a 13.7% savings to be made by using this combination, and given my time in using IT (since 1974) and supplying IT support services (since 1998) a simple domain controller is a whole lot less time intensive to support (=more $$$) than a small business server running exchange.
Reason
- A Small business server requires more resources to run exchange as well as the normal server functions. This leads to a higher capital cost.
- The cost of Microsoft software and the user licenses is vastly more expensive than their Foundation server product. This leads to a higher capital cost.
Cons:
- This exercise was only done for 12 users, which enabled us to specify the Foundation server product. If we were to have more than 15 users then doing it yourself rather than outsourcing the email has a better price as the base server license has a greater price.
- Small business servers are a wonderful thing and add more than just email to a server’s normal function. Not all clients require that functionality, yet some do.
Contact us for a FREE assessment and quote on your upgrade or replacement server. We can talk cloud or hybrid or conventional – Whatever is best for your business.







